The SEC recently achieved a significant victory in its campaign to use the “clawback” provision under Sarbanes-Oxley to force the return of incentive-based compensation by CEOs and CFOs to issuers, even when they are not personally responsible for any alleged “misconduct.” SEC v. Jenkins, No. CV 09-1510-PHX-GMS (D. Ariz. June 9, 2010). The court in Jenkins denied a motion to dismiss the SEC’s complaint seeking an order directing Maynard L. Jenkins, the former CEO of CSK Auto Corporation, to pay back to CSK over $4 million in bonuses and stock sale proceeds that Jenkins received during a period for which CSK’s financial statements were later restated. The case is noteworthy because the SEC has pointedly not charged Jenkins with any wrongdoing, notwithstanding that other former CSK executives have faced both civil and criminal accounting fraud charges. (See our memo, SEC Pursues Unprecedented Sarbanes-Oxley “Clawback,” July 24, 2009.)

(more…)