One of the more surprising developments around the SEC’s proposed Rule 14a-8 rescission is that one of the rule’s arch critics is having second thoughts. The Heritage Foundation has been one of the most vocal critics of proxy advisers, ESG and “woke investment,” but now that its own remedy has turned against the agenda it was meant to serve, it seems distinctly unhappy with the SEC’s direction of travel.

Heritage’s own use of the rule explains the discomfort. Bowyer Research and Heritage’s American Investor Initiative report a roughly 50% rate of getting companies to concede ground through engagement on anti-ESG proposals, and a 100% rate of getting those proposals onto the ballot: access and negotiation, not votes won. Minerva Analytics’ Shareholder Proposal Voting Trends 2026 H1 briefing shows how little of that access converts into support: average shareholder backing for anti-ESG proposals in 2026 sat at around 1.7%, none passing, consistent with the prior two seasons.

(more…)