Subodh Mishra is the Global Head of Communications at ISS STOXX. This post is based on an ISS STOXX Governance Research report.
Key Takeaways
- The U.S. governance framework is entering a period of significant transition, with proposed SEC reforms potentially reshaping shareholder proposals, exempt solicitations, executive compensation disclosure, and say-on-pay voting. The 2026 ISS Global Benchmark Policy Survey results provide an indication of how investors may respond as that landscape evolves.
- Some long-established shareholder mechanisms may become less available. If proposed changes to shareholder proposals and exempt solicitations move forward, the mechanisms available to investors to engage, raise concerns, and communicate with companies could change significantly, potentially leading many investors to place greater emphasis on other avenues for accountability.
- Investor focus remains firmly on shareholder rights. The survey results suggest investors generally support weighing all factors in assessing re-incorporation decisions but place particular importance on preserving mechanisms that allow shareholders to hold boards and management accountable.
- Investors may adapt by placing greater future voting emphasis on director elections for accountability. As shareholder proposals and advisory say-on-pay votes potentially become less available, the survey results suggest that investors may increasingly look to director elections as avenues for expressing governance concerns through voting.
- Executive compensation disclosure and oversight could change substantially. The SEC’s proposed reforms would exempt many companies from existing compensation disclosure requirements and say-on-pay votes, a change that could affect a large portion of the U.S. market. The SEC estimates that approximately 81% of public companies would qualify for the proposed changes.
- Many investors will continue to expect accountability for pay decisions. Even in the absence of say-on-pay votes, most investor respondents to the survey supported some form of board-level accountability, particularly through compensation committee leadership. Half favored initially focusing accountability on the compensation committee chair and escalating only if concerns persist over multiple years, while 41% supported directing concerns toward compensation committee members more broadly from the start.
- Investors continue to value executive compensation transparency, while recognizing that commercial sensitivities on performance targets can be legitimate. Over 70 percent of investor respondents answered either that competitive harm may justify non-disclosure in certain circumstances—after considering the company’s specific explanation and facts on a case-by-case basis—or with retrospective disclosure.
- Investors are particularly skeptical of non-disclosure for relative performance metrics. Nearly 80% of investor respondents agreed that competitive harm is a less compelling rationale for withholding relative performance goals.
- As investors may increasingly look to directors for accountability, director independence is likely to receive greater scrutiny. Approximately 64% of investor respondents indicated that lengthy director tenure should be considered in independence assessments, even though this is not currently a standard market practice in the United States.
- Investors favor a holistic approach to board independence and tenure. Rather than using mechanical director tenure limits, respondents generally supported evaluating tenure and independence in the context of broader factors such as board refreshment, leadership structure, and long-term board tenure overlaps.

