Ferhat Akbas is the Constantin Mihas Chair and Professor of Finance at the University of Illinois Chicago (UIC), Minjie Huang is Associate Professor of Finance at the University of Louisville, and Felix Meschke is Associate Professor of Finance at the University of Kansas School of Business. This post is based on their recent article, forthcoming in the Journal of Finance.
Should unusually heavy short selling before disappointing earnings raise greater concern about an information leak at a family firm? An influential study in the Journal of Finance by Ronald Anderson, David Reeb, and Wanli Zhao answered yes. The authors found that short selling predicted returns in family firms but not in nonfamily firms. They also reported almost 17 times more abnormal short selling before negative earnings announcements in family firms than in nonfamily firms and suggested that disputes within controlling families could give short sellers access to private information.
Yet short sellers are skilled at analyzing companies and uncovering problems that other investors miss. That skill should be useful in nonfamily firms, too.
In our recent study in the Journal of Finance, we revisit those findings. Anderson and Reeb made their family-firm data available, allowing us to study the same firms and period using a more comprehensive record of short-selling activity. We find that short selling predicts returns in both family and nonfamily firms. We also find no evidence that pre-announcement short selling is more sensitive to negative earnings news in family firms.

