The backlash against ESG in the United States has been unmistakable in 2023. More than one-third of states have passed anti-ESG laws in 2023, most ESG-related shareholder proposals failed to garner majority support, new lawsuits have been filed challenging companies’ ESG-related activities and decisions, and some companies seem to be distancing themselves from the term “ESG” itself. But despite a heavy stream of opinion pieces, the business case for incorporating non-financial metrics into an evaluation of a company’s risk and opportunity profile (the very crux of ESG efforts) remains clear.
Instead, companies’ on-the-ground approaches to their ESG strategies are evolving in response to recent events. With proxy season complete, the Supreme Court term wrapped, Congress in recess and most state legislatures adjourned, we take stock of the current state of ESG for U.S. companies.
Proxy Season: A Drop in Support for E&S Shareholder Proposals
While shareholders can use engagement tools throughout the year to express their priorities and concerns, the casting of votes during proxy season is when shareholder views have the most acute impact. In recent years, proxy season has catalyzed the focus on ESG issues as many institutional investors made oversight and management of those issues both an engagement priority and a component of their voting policies. In response, public companies have been propelled to make changes. In large numbers, they have increased their voluntary reporting on ESG issues, implemented and amended ESG-related policies, set ESG-related goals and targets (including verified science-based targets), and appointed executives to oversee sustainability efforts.
Support for shareholder proposals has undoubtedly been an important part of this activity. For example, in 2021 a record 36 shareholder proposals relating to environmental and social (“E&S”) issues received majority support. The most successful of these proposals related to issues involving the disclosure of workforce diversity (EEO-1) data, or reports on climate change transition plans, greenhouse gas emissions or targets. Since that time, a growing number of companies have begun disclosing this type of data.
READ MORE »